Discussion in 'Math Research' started by Michael J Hardy, Jun 3, 2005.

  1. See <>.

    Recently it was stated in this newsgroup that anyone can post
    anything they want there. I think that is misleading. When
    you edit one of these pages, people are watching. If you
    insert an obscenity, it will probably be deleted within minutes.
    If you delete all of the content of an article, ditto.
    If you put in a misspelling, it may take longer. If you put an
    erronenous mathematical assertion, it may not take long.
    Hundreds of mathematicians have worked on Wikipedia. If you
    edit an article that a logged-in user has put on his watchlist
    (logged-in users can do that), then he will know what you did
    the next time he clicks on "my watchlist". If you click on
    "history" or "page history" you will see who has contributed
    what to the article, on what dates (and times, to the minute).

    The result, as far as math articles go, is that

    (1) articles on topics that only mathematicians are likely
    to know about are often quite good;

    (2) articles on topics such as calculus that zillions of
    students take are sometimes clumsily written, but even there,
    those who edit are usually eager to learn from those who know
    more -- otherwise they wouldn't be there.

    And sometimes people get banned for not behaving themselves.

    The URL above says "list of lists of ...", not just "list of..."

    That page is a remarkable table of contents of mathematics.
    Some of the lists contain perhaps a couple of hundred math
    articles; some have only a couple of dozen or so. -- Mike Hardy
    Michael J Hardy, Jun 3, 2005
    1. Advertisements

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.